XML & Web Services

Why I prefer Sharpreader and w.bloggar over NewsGator

I came across the new version of NewsGator yesterday, including support for posting…

some facts keep me from using it – and preferring Sharpreader for reading with pluged-in w.bloggar for posting:

  • Performance: the aggregated frontpagewith 115 feeds I read takes aprox. 1,5 min. on my Athlon 2200 to build – with 100% CPU utilization
  • Usability: an outlook problem for a decade – the folder-“new“counts are not aggregated (i.e. a folder with 3 sub-folders having 1 new entry each does not display that there are 3 new overall inside – don’t blame NewsGator – it’s Outlook
  • Usability: no time-based filtering – actually no directory-based filtering at all – I cannot find relevant posts when I have to klick through all 115 feeds (see picture with example “Microsoft in last 12 hours”)
  • Usability: no possibility to read a whole group of feeds together, i.e. clicking on the directory like “Java” to get all feeds below sorted in the way I want it (time, alphatext, etc.)
  • Publishing: no HTML-editing, no FTP-upload of pics, not even possibility to enter an URL with a specific text different to the URL-text, no stylesheet-support for MT-Plugin (maybe others do better), no category-download (ok, again an Outlook problem) therefore need to manual update it…
  • Commercial: I would have to pay money to use it – no way with these lacks of usabilty


example of a time-based filter query in Sharpreader

well, therefore I uninstalled version 1.3 today, despite some other features like offline posting might let me come back – for a different, corporate, setup and different version at a later point…

Average rating
(0 votes)

Comments

Why I prefer Sharpreader and w.bloggar over NewsGator

Hello, I thought I'd post a few things in regards to this.

Performance - yes, the NewsPage is currently pretty slow...we're working on this. However, it seems like most users migrate away from the NewsPage toward using just the Outlook folders themselves, after using NewsGator for a while. Also on Outlook 2003, many folks prefer using a "Unread News" search folder (example at http://www.rassoc.com/gregr/weblog/archive.aspx?post=575) over the NewsPage.

Filtering - yes and no. On Outlook 2000/2002, you can use the Find capability built into Outlook for certain kinds of filtering. And you can use an Advanced Find to find just about anything you'd like. On Outlook 2003, you can create a search folder to pull messages into a "virtual folder" based on any criteria you'd like - definitely worth a look.

Publishing -

No HTML editing? You can certainly edit your posts with Outlook's HTML editors...not sure what you're referring to here.

Enter URL with specific text different from URL text? You can definitely do this...simply highlight the text in the editor, go to Insert/Hyperlink, and type the URL. This is with Outlook's built-in editor; I believe the sequence is slightly different if you're using the MS Word editor within Outlook.

Hope this helps...and I hope you come back! :-)

Greg

Similar entries

  • Just on Business Wire read that NewsGator 1.3, an outlook-integrated RSS newsfeed reader – was released with new Newsgroup support (NNTP) in addition to the RSS reading capabilities for outlook. They also promise an offline posting mode – composing stuff…

  • Can you believe it? No application found for offline browsing RSS channels via my P800 (with J2ME support or native) – neither Opensource nor Commercial – nothing! Read about my findings for online-browsing and a very promising palm-solution that should be worth the effort to be ported to EPOC/Symbian.

  • new SharpReader RSS Reader

  • Oh well – VentureCap times are in again I guess… is the whole market crazy about blogs, content aggregation and text ads ? I think so… People start pouring money into a newsreader company creating NewsGator and explain it… Why…