Projects & Management

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

I would like to point to the most important motivation theories, because I have not seen such a summary before in a blog and this was yet another little part of the extensive christmas present we got from our business english lecturer…

MASLOW'S THEORY OF MOTIVATION AND HUMAN NEEDS Maslow's classical theory is taught in every basic management course. Structuring the dependency of needs of human beings is a good beginning when starting to analyze humans in general.

McGregor's Factor X/Y theory theory categorizes employees in two types and explains possible behavior of their managers. Even if I know that at least these two types exists I believe it?s a too broad spectrum in human behavior to explain it with these two types.

The Hawthorne study found out that employees got more motivated as soon as they recognized that they got more attention than before. It was illustrated with the example of changing lights in the factory where only the change of light intensity was important, not if it was brighter or darker. interesting, huh?

Herzberg's Two Factor Theory extends Maslow's model very well. It?s actually obvious that people cannot be motivated without giving them a feeling of security or acceptance first. It applies very well to the situation with motivation in the workplace because it explains the needs for correct "hygiene factors" like expected salary, a good work place with proper lighting and desks for example.

The equity theory assumes that the own social comparison of employees to their peers is the most important factor for motivation. The expectancy theory suggests that people are motivated to work toward rewards, bonuses and other goodies. In my opinion only a combination of these two, with the expectancy theory following the equity theory in relevance, is a valid approach. I do not believe in only the social aspects and mind-setting of employees, although the social position and treatment is probably the required precursor before additional goodies and goals can create a vital effect on motivation.

While searching for some relevant link resources I found Scholl's page with class Notes for students in Doctoral, Masters, and Undergraduate courses in Management, Organizational Behavior, and Labor Relations and Human Resources…. pretty comprehensive page indeed… :-)

Average rating
(1 vote)

Comments

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

I've always been of the opinion that if the project doesn't motivate the programmer then the programmer will never motivate the code.

I'm in the middle of reading "Software Craftsmanship" by Peter McBreen and his message is pretty clear. Pay your programmers what they are worth. It's a good starting point.

Regards
Jase

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

@Peter,

You are absolutely right - I do not believe that one of those theries explains humand behaviours complete... but my experience has shown, that both Herzberg and Maslow are right when it comes to some cases ... they even overlap in some manner..

- example1 Herzberg: as long as you are angry about your low salargy you are not motivated - no matter how interesting the job might be...
- example2 Maslow: if the low salary does not make you angry, you might feel unsafe about how to feed your familiy, pay your loans or whatever... you are not only not motivated, you are blocked by thoughts about your safety... the lowest level (security) overweights everything else...

the same could go for good project colleagues, your personal interests reflected at work, etc..

kind regards,christoph

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

please let me know how i can make a project on human resourse management.

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

send me the notes on Human resourse managment in doc format

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

hello

i was wondering if anyone here can provide me a link to any website where a comprehensive comparison has been made between maslow's and herzberg's motivation theories

thanks

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

hello

i was wondering if anyone here can provide me a link to any website where a comprehensive comparison has been made between maslow's and herzberg's motivation theories

thanks

Top Motivation Theories explained and compared

Hello!,

can we have a detail link/reference to motivational success stories in the indian corporate sector, industry vertical wise, as that will provide an insight to the validity of the various motivational theories of thE past & current & refine our learnings to today's context
REGARDS
AROON MEHTA
INDIA.

Similar entries